Among the quarterbacks eligible for the 2024 NFL Draft, J.J. McCarthy stands out as the most enigmatic figure. Initially considered a borderline first-round pick after the National Championship, McCarthy’s draft stock was uncertain, potentially slipping to the second round depending on teams’ post-free agency trade priorities. However, after an impressive showing at the NFL Combine, McCarthy solidified his position as a strong contender within the top 15 picks. Now, with a recent report from Forbes, there’s speculation that McCarthy might even be selected within the top five if circumstances align favorably.
The Minnesota Vikings Are Likely Setting Up For J.J. McCarthy
Earlier this week, the Minnesota Vikings experienced the loss of their starting quarterback, Kirk Cousins, who moved to the Atlanta Falcons. In an unexpected turn of events, they swiftly recruited Sam Darnold from the LA Rams as his replacement. This sudden acquisition raised eyebrows, as Darnold, though a competent quarterback with potential, doesn’t typically fit the profile of a player swiftly acquired within 24 hours of losing a franchise quarterback.
In addition to securing Darnold, the Vikings engaged in a picks exchange with the Houston Texans. Under this deal, the Vikings acquired the No. 23 and 232nd picks for this year, while the Texans received No. 42, 188, and a second-round pick in 2025. Although obtaining the 23rd pick may not initially seem advantageous for moving up, it’s crucial to note that the Vikings also hold the No. 11 pick overall. This could prove enticing for teams like the LA Chargers or the Atlanta Falcons, who are not necessarily seeking a quarterback or an extremely high draft pick.
Sam Darnold Is a Solid Option at QB Short Term of Backup
If the Vikings were to acquire J.J. McCarthy, they would have a dependable option alongside Sam Darnold. Darnold could serve as either a short-term starter, allowing McCarthy time to adjust to the NFL, or ignite a fierce quarterback competition for the starting role. Regardless, Darnold is recognized as a top-tier backup and, potentially for teams like the Vikings next season, a starter with the potential for career revitalization.
It’s improbable that the Vikings will refrain from drafting a quarterback. While they might consider relying on Darnold in 2024, they are keen to avoid a scenario where he is their sole option, especially if he underperforms or suffers an injury. Last season, the Vikings faced a predicament when they had to rely on their fourth-string quarterback due to a lack of capable backups.
Conclusion
There’s little uncertainty that the Bears, Commanders, and Patriots will opt for the initial three quarterbacks in the NFL Draft, as all three teams have a pressing need for quarterbacks. While there are rumors suggesting the Patriots might lean towards McCarthy over Drake Maye, the prevailing sentiment points towards Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, and Drake Maye as the top three picks.
Bo Nix and Michael Penix Jr. are also on the radar as potential first-round quarterbacks, albeit with a slightly higher risk factor compared to McCarthy. McCarthy seems to offer a safer bet with a proven track record over the past two seasons at Michigan, although his ceiling might not be as high.
Should the Vikings hold a strong interest in McCarthy, they currently possess the resources and first-round picks to make a move for him if they’re sufficiently motivated.
